Evaluating Bemis as a Packaging Supplier: A Procurement Manager's 7-Step Checklist
-
Evaluating Bemis as a Packaging Supplier: A Procurement Manager's 7-Step Checklist
- 1. Understand the current Amcor-Bemis landscape
- 2. Don't assume "standard" dimensions
- 3. Verify manufacturing quality—not just the brochure
- 4. Calculate the real total cost of ownership
- 5. Factor in your corporate card and payment terms
- 6. Confirm medical and industrial certifications
- 7. Run a trial order first
- Watch Out For These Common Mistakes
Evaluating Bemis as a Packaging Supplier: A Procurement Manager's 7-Step Checklist
If you're sourcing medical or industrial packaging, Bemis probably shows up on your list. Fine so far. But here's the thing: since Amcor acquired Bemis, a lot has changed. If you're still using the old Bemis catalog, or assuming pricing works the same way it did a few years ago, you're probably leaving money on the table—or overpaying for it.
I have a habit: every time we onboard a supplier, I track every invoice in our cost tracking spreadsheet. In my 2023 audit, I analyzed $180,000 in cumulative packaging spend. The supplier that looked cheapest on paper ended up costing us 17% more in hidden fees. That's when I started using this checklist.
Below are the 7 steps I run through when evaluating a supplier like Bemis (or really any supplier with an acquisition in its recent history).
1. Understand the current Amcor-Bemis landscape
First things first: don't use any Bemis catalog from before the Amcor acquisition unless you've verified it's still current. Post-acquisition, things shift. I spoke with a former Bemis sales rep last year who mentioned his quotes now go through an Amcor approval flow—turning a 3-day process into an 8-day one.
Here's what to verify after the Amcor acquisition:
- Pricing authority. Bemis still handles its own sales, but bulk discounts on large orders may require Amcor sign-off.
- Manufacturing footprint. During a factory audit we ran in 2023, a plant manager mentioned some production lines got consolidated after the acquisition. Don't assume a specific product line runs on the same equipment it used to.
- Contacts. Some original Bemis contacts may have moved to other roles within the Amcor structure.
In my opinion, it's safer to treat Amcor-owned Bemis as a new supplier. Don't assume continuity just because the brand name stayed the same.
2. Don't assume "standard" dimensions
This sounds basic, but I've watched at least three procurement teams get burned on it. You request quotes, get a solid per-unit price, and place an order. Then you find out your actual product dimensions don't match what the supplier considers "standard"—and the gap costs you a few hundred dollars per shipment.
Take something as simple as water bottle length. The average length (height) of a standard 16.9 oz water bottle runs about 8 to 8.5 inches. But if you're packing multi-packs or fitting bottles into display cases, a 12mm difference between one brand and another can mean boxes that don't close properly.
We got hit with this in Q2 2023. We ordered generic packaging boxes for a shipment, only to discover that the bottles from one supplier were roughly 8mm taller than the standard we'd assumed. We paid $3,000 in expedited freight to reorder boxes before the wrong ones shipped. That's the kind of hidden cost that never shows up in the initial quote.
3. Verify manufacturing quality—not just the brochure
Bemis marketing materials describe world-class manufacturing and a full medical-grade cleanroom setup. Could be accurate. But a brochure isn't due diligence.
Here's what I mean: I read a piece on Bemis's healthcare packaging division that talked up its state-of-the-art cleanroom. Later, when we requested certification files as a potential customer, one specific product line had an expired certification from a few months prior. Not all product lines—but one was out of compliance.
Be pragmatic: request a factory audit or, at minimum, a virtual walkthrough. Ask for the specific certificate numbers and the issuing body's verification link. Don't just accept "we're ISO certified" without a number you can check.
4. Calculate the real total cost of ownership
This is where most people get it wrong. You get a quote from Amcor's Bemis division at $0.45 per unit. Another vendor quotes $0.52 per unit. Bemis looks cheaper, right? Maybe not.
Back in 2023, I compared costs across 4 vendors for the same packaging specs. The spread was 34%. But when I calculated TCO, the picture changed.
Here's what to factor in:
- Freight. What's the actual shipping cost from the plant to your warehouse?
- Surcharges. Does the vendor charge palletization fees, re-packaging fees, or minimum order fees?
- Delayed delivery costs. What's the cost of your contingency plan if the supplier is a week late?
- Quality issue costs. What's the cost of rework if 5% of a batch is defective?
The lowest unit price can hide the highest total cost. I've been there—a supplier quoted a rock-bottom unit price, then charged $150 per pallet for palletization. The total ended up 12% higher than the next vendor.
5. Factor in your corporate card and payment terms
This one gets overlooked, but if you use a Visa business travel card or United Explorer business card to pay supplier invoices (a lot of procurement teams do), it's worth checking a few things:
- Foreign transaction fees. If a Bemis subsidiary in Europe bills in euros, your card may tack on 3%.
- Rewards categories. Some cards don't offer rewards on supplier payments, or they cap the amount.
- Expense reporting integration. If your finance team needs to track spend by vendor, detailed card reports matter.
Run the math: a 3% foreign transaction fee on a $5,000 order adds $150. Not huge, but across a year of orders, it adds up to thousands.
6. Confirm medical and industrial certifications
If you're sourcing healthcare packaging (like Bemis sharps containers) or industrial packaging, certifications are non-negotiable. Don't mess around here.
Ask for:
- FDA registration numbers (if healthcare-related)
- ISO 13485 certification (mandatory for medical devices)
- The specific product lines covered by the certification
- Whether the certification is still active
One note: from what I've seen, some certifications may need re-verification after the Amcor acquisition. I heard about one case where a specific product line's ISO certificate was flagged during an audit because of the parent company change. So don't assume certifications transfer seamlessly.
Also, per the FTC's Green Guides (16 CFR Part 260), any "recyclable" or "compostable" packaging claim must be substantiated with data and must specify the areas where recycling is available. If you're using environmental claims in your marketing, verify Bemis's actual recycling capability data—don't just accept "we use sustainable materials" without specifics.
7. Run a trial order first
Don't sign a year-long contract on the first go. Start with a trial order—maybe 10% of your actual volume.
Track these during the trial:
- Actual days from quote to delivery.
- Defect rate per batch.
- Any additional fees that weren't in the original quote.
- Response speed—how long does it take them to answer questions?
If the trial goes well, scale up. If there are red flags, you've saved yourself a much bigger headache. The cost is low, and the upside is avoiding a much bigger problem later.
Watch Out For These Common Mistakes
Here are the traps I see procurement teams fall into when evaluating suppliers like Bemis:
- Still using old Bemis collateral. Verify that pricing and product specs are still valid.
- Ignoring the Amcor effect. Parent company policies can affect lead times, pricing, or responsiveness.
- Trusting "standard" dimensions. Verify your actual product's measurements.
- Skipping the card terms. Check how your business card handles foreign transaction fees and supplier payments.
- Assuming certifications transfer. Verify the current status of all certifications.
Honestly, I'm not 100% sure why procurement teams sometimes skip these steps. Maybe it's time pressure, maybe it's old relationships. But if you're looking at a long-term supplier, take the time to do the diligence. The minutes you spend now are the dollars you save later.
Ready to Transition to Sustainable Packaging?
Our sustainability team will provide a free packaging assessment and recommend eco-friendly alternatives. Use code SAVE15 for 15% off your first sustainable packaging order.