Why I Now Review Every Supplier Twice a Year โ Instead of Once Every Five
I almost missed the fact that one of our main packaging suppliers had been acquired years ago
I'm the office administrator for a 150-person company. We do contract sterilization for medical device clients. I handle all the purchasing โ from office supplies to packaging materials โ roughly $150,000 a year spread across about a dozen vendors. I report to both operations and finance.
I took over purchasing in 2020. My predecessor left me a vendor spreadsheet that I basically renamed and started using. Why would I question it? Prices were reasonable, deliveries showed up on time, invoices cleared. It worked.
That was my mistake.
In spring 2024, we kicked off an office refresh project. Not the fun "let's paint an accent wall" kind. The "we need everything done in a month" kind. We needed to order:
- A large branded poster for the cafeteria wall. Marketing had googled how big is a 24 by 36 poster and realized that 24" ร 36" is actually pretty massive โ 864 square inches. And then they discovered that USPS defines a large envelope (flat) as having a maximum dimension of 12" ร 15". So our poster had to ship in a reinforced tube. The shipping cost made finance wince.
- Water filtration bottles for the office kitchen. Staff had been asking to cut down on single-use plastic, and this seemed like a reasonable middle ground. We were comparing a few models.
- Coffee supplies. This one came with an unexpected question from finance: how much caffeine is in a cup of coffee? Apparently someone on the team had raised a concern about caffeine sensitivity during a meeting. I didn't have a solid number. I still don't, honestly โ caffeine content varies wildly by brew method and bean. I just told them I'd look into it and moved on.
All of this was happening while my operations director asked me to audit our packaging suppliers. We were up for a contract renewal on the medical side. For context, we used Bemis healthcare packaging and sharps containers โ had been for years. Our clients specified certain packaging specs, and Bemis met them. Fine.
When I pulled up the vendor spreadsheet, the Bemis row said: "Bemis โ independent packaging supplier." Contact info from 2019. No other notes.
Something made me pause. I typed "amcor bemis" into the browser.
Pages of results.
It turned out that Amcor had acquired Bemis years ago. I'd heard about it vaguely at some point, but it wasn't in my spreadsheet, wasn't in our contract files, wasn't anywhere in our records. We were still treating them like an independent company.
I felt stupid. Not because I'd missed the news โ but because I hadn't thought to check.
The audit that got uncomfortable fast
Once I started pulling that thread, other things unraveled.
Two other vendors on our list had changed parent companies or ownership structures within the last 18 months. One had changed its name entirely. Another had a billing entity that no longer matched our purchase orders โ which explained why a handful of invoices had been stuck in finance for weeks.
The real cost wasn't financial, though. It was the look on my operations director's face when I told him we'd been operating on stale information. Not angry โ just concerned. "Do we have a process for checking this?"
We didn't.
The part that made me rethink everything
Here's what I realized: this wasn't just a spreadsheet problem. It was a mindset problem.
Five years ago, a good supplier was one who quoted a fair price and delivered on time. That's still true. But in 2024, you also need to know who owns them, whether their invoicing process has changed, whether their certifications are up to date, and whether they've been acquired or merged. The fundamentals haven't changed, but the execution has transformed.
I learned that the hard way when we discovered during a quarterly review that one of our vendors had been acquired by a larger group, and their purchase order system no longer matched our internal records. We'd been issuing PO numbers that their system didn't recognize, which triggered manual reviews on their end and delayed our orders. Nobody caught it until finance flagged the pattern.
And I'll be honest: I still don't have hard data on how much time we wasted on those delays. What I can say anecdotally is that it added at least a week to two separate projects.
The "always get three quotes" rule I'd been taught? It ignores the transaction cost of vendor evaluation and the value of established relationships. Switching suppliers to save a few percentage points doesn't help if the new vendor's back office is a mess.
How I fixed it (mostly)
I did three things:
- I pulled every vendor contract and cross-referenced current ownership status. This took hours. For two vendors, I had to call their customer service lines to confirm who owned them โ which is always a fun conversation.
- I set a recurring calendar reminder to review each vendor every six months. Not just pricing โ ownership, invoicing contacts, and certification status.
- I added three columns to our internal spreadsheet: "Parent Company," "Invoice Contact," and "Last Verified." Simple fixes, but necessary ones.
The best part: when I went back and actually looked at Bemis healthcare packaging, I noticed that their updated product line included some options we could use immediately. So the audit actually paid for itself.
There's something satisfying about getting a shipment of reinforced mailing tubes for those 24" ร 36" posters and having them arrive intact โ no shipping damage, no back-and-forth. That was the first time in months that an office project went smoothly on the first try. The water filtration bottles got installed in the kitchen. The coffee supplies arrived without incident. And finance stopped asking me about caffeine math.
One thing I added to our vendor review checklist: verifying any environmental claims. Per FTC Green Guides (16 CFR Part 260), a vendor that claims their packaging is "recyclable" or "compostable" needs to substantiate that with evidence. We ask for it now. Better safe than sorry.
What I'd tell another admin buyer
If you're managing supplier relationships, here's what I've learned (the hard way, so you don't have to):
1. Treat vendor audits like a check-up, not a repair job.
You don't wait until something breaks. Set a six-month reminder. Take 30 minutes to verify that your records match reality. It saves hours of scrambling later.
2. Assume your records are stale until proven otherwise.
The reason I caught the Amcor/Bemis situation was that I paused and thought, "Why does this invoice look different?" instead of just filing it. Ask the annoying questions.
3. The "three quotes" rule ignores relationships.
Yes, price matters. But when a vendor goes out of their way โ like finding us the right reinforced tube packaging or flagging a product line update โ that's worth something. Not everything can be measured on a spreadsheet.
I don't claim to have this all figured out. I still have a lot to learn. But at least now I know that keeping vendor records current isn't a one-time task. It's an ongoing thing. And honestly, I'd rather spend 30 minutes every six months than have finance breathing down my neck about unexplained invoice discrepancies.
What was best practice in 2020 doesn't necessarily apply in 2025. That's just how it goes.
Ready to Transition to Sustainable Packaging?
Our sustainability team will provide a free packaging assessment and recommend eco-friendly alternatives. Use code SAVE15 for 15% off your first sustainable packaging order.